Coin Review Count

American Silver Eagle

2008 American Silver Eagle

2008-W American Silver Eagle

The American Silver Eagle is the silver bullion coin of the United States. It has been produced since 1986 as a one ounce bullion coin and collectible proof coin. Recently, Silver Eagles have been offered as a collectible uncirculated coin. The obverse design is based on Adolph A. Weinman’s Walking Liberty Half Dollar. The reverse of the coin featuring a heraldic eagle was designed by John Mercanti.

7 Positive Reviews and 0 Negative Reviews

Average Ratings:

Coin Design4.864.864.864.864.86
Historical Significance4.714.714.714.714.71
Investment Potential55555
Overall Rating55555

Categories: United States Bullion Coins

8 Reviews for “American Silver Eagle”

  1. Is it possible for us collectors to clamor for at least a limited run of the Silver Eagle Proof and uncirculated version for 2009. The mint is running a risk of the first mintage break in this series! We collectors have spent a ton of money on them so far. The mint makes good money on them. What gives here????

    Ratings:

    Coin Design55555
    Historical Significance55555
    Investment Potential55555
    Overall Rating55555

  2. Beautiful, classic design. It’s too bad the U.S. Mint relies so heavily on St. Gaudens’ designs for other bullion coins, though. How about some originality, as was shown with the Gold Buffalo?

    Ratings:

    Coin Design55555
    Historical Significance55555
    Investment Potential55555
    Overall Rating55555

  3. A great coin and a great design. The eagle’s wings need to be spread more and the mint mark put on the front. Still, this one is a real winner. Will be popular for years to come.

    Ratings:

    Coin Design44444
    Historical Significance55555
    Investment Potential55555
    Overall Rating55555

  4. A great coin design. I fear the Mint feels detailed coin designs are an antiquated approach to coin design, but this is not the case. This coin has a contemporary flavor to it!

    My only quibble is that the reverse might have been improved a tad with some sunrays above or around the Eagle, perhaps as a field for the stars.

    Ratings:

    Coin Design55555
    Historical Significance33333
    Investment Potential55555
    Overall Rating55555

  5. One of America’s best coin designs and a great large silver coin. Can’t get enough of them.

    Ratings:

    Coin Design55555
    Historical Significance55555
    Investment Potential55555
    Overall Rating55555

  6. Question: If so short on blanks for silver coins, why all these other coins have priority over the silver eagle? Are our subscriptions for silver eagles still good, or have they swamped them also? I think the mint has gone the way as the rest of this government( wasn’t it the only profit makeing part of the government until this year?) Thanks…kent

    Ratings:

    Coin DesignNot Rated
    Historical SignificanceNot Rated
    Investment PotentialNot Rated
    Overall RatingNot Rated

  7. Already an American classic, with a worthy design and highly collected by the numismatic community as well as by bullion investor’s. I must add here that the U.S. Mint has done a superb job producing these one ounce .999 fine Silver bullion coins from day one.

    Ratings:

    Coin Design55555
    Historical Significance55555
    Investment Potential55555
    Overall Rating55555

  8. Wow I’m the first to review this coin! I would have thought people would jump all over this one. This is one of my favorites. Even though the design is not original I think it is outstanding! You can’t mess with perfection. The obverse is emblematic of Liberty. I like how the reverse comes together with the eagle, the shield and the thirteen stars.

    Historically, it brings the new and the traditional all together in what we’ve come to expect in a superb American coin. That might not be historical, but I just can’t ding this coin.

    Investment-wise… it’s silver… and I like that just like I like gold.

    Ratings:

    Coin Design55555
    Historical Significance55555
    Investment Potential55555
    Overall Rating55555

Review this coin

Coin Design
Historical Significance
Investment Potential
Overall Rating